How Companies Make Money on Black Friday Even at 70% Off

Black Friday has become one of the biggest shopping events of the year, with retailers advertising discounts of 50%, 60% and even 70% off merchandise. From televisions and appliances to clothing, toys, beauty products and electronics, the promotions are designed to convince consumers they are getting extraordinary deals. But behind those eye-catching price tags is a carefully calculated business strategy that allows companies to generate revenue even when products appear to be selling for a fraction of their original prices.

Consider JCPenney. According to personal finance company WalletHub’s 2025 Black Friday analysis, the retailer offered an average advertised discount of 74.08%, the highest among 13 major retailers examined. Belk followed at 72.42%, while Kohl’s averaged 45.39%.

Those numbers raise an obvious question: How can a retailer offer an average discount of nearly 75% and still make money? The answer involves more than the price of an individual product. Retailers use loss leaders, additional purchases, store credit cards, extended warranties, exclusive merchandise, limited inventory and customer loyalty programs to turn discounted transactions into larger business opportunities.

Black Friday is not simply about selling products cheaply. It is about getting customers through the door, encouraging them to spend more and building relationships that can generate revenue long after the shopping event ends.

The 70% Discount Is Not Always What It Appears to Be

One of the biggest misconceptions about Black Friday is that every advertised discount represents a comparable reduction from the price consumers would normally pay. Retailers frequently advertise products using a manufacturer’s suggested retail price, an original price or a previous selling price. However, those figures do not necessarily reflect what customers have been paying for the merchandise.

For example, imagine a television advertised at $1,000 with a Black Friday price of $300. The retailer promotes the purchase as 70% off. But what if comparable televisions have regularly sold for $350? The advertised savings would look significantly more impressive than the difference between the Black Friday price and the product’s recent market price.

That does not automatically mean the promotion is deceptive. However, the Federal Trade Commission has established guidelines governing former-price comparisons. Under the FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, a retailer’s former price must represent a genuine price at which the merchandise was openly and actively offered for sale for a reasonably substantial period. Artificially inflating a previous price to advertise a larger discount can constitute deceptive pricing. The distinction matters because consumers often judge a deal by the percentage displayed rather than the product’s actual pricing history.

How Loss Leaders Help Retailers Make Money

One of the oldest retail strategies is the loss leader. A loss leader is a product intentionally sold at a very low profit margin or even below cost to attract customers into a store. During Black Friday, televisions, gaming consoles, appliances and other popular electronics frequently become promotional attractions.

A retailer might sell a television for considerably less than its usual price because the company expects customers to purchase additional merchandise during the same shopping trip. Someone who arrives at 5 a.m. to purchase a discounted television might also leave with an HDMI cable, wall mount, soundbar, streaming device or extended protection plan.

The television attracts the customer. The additional purchases create opportunities for the retailer to generate more revenue. This strategy works because companies evaluate more than the profitability of a single product. They also consider the total amount customers spend during a transaction. A heavily discounted television might generate little profit on its own, but the complete purchase could be considerably more valuable.

Extended Warranties and Accessories Create Additional Revenue

Electronics retailers have another opportunity to make money after customers select their discounted products. Extended warranties and protection plans are frequently offered during checkout, particularly for expensive electronics, appliances and computers.

These plans provide customers with additional coverage beyond the manufacturer’s standard warranty, depending on the terms and exclusions. For retailers, protection plans can generate additional revenue without requiring another major merchandise purchase.

Accessories also play an important role. A discounted laptop might require a mouse, carrying case, keyboard or software subscription. A new television could lead to purchases of mounting equipment, cables and audio accessories.

Retailers understand that customers shopping for one major purchase may be willing to spend additional money to complete the experience. That is why the advertised price of a product does not necessarily tell the entire story of how much a retailer expects to earn from the transaction.

Store Credit Cards Can Be a Major Source of Profit

One of the most financially significant parts of Black Friday happens at checkout. Retailers frequently encourage customers to open store credit cards by offering an immediate discount, promotional financing or rewards on their purchases.

For example, a shopper spending $500 might receive an additional percentage off by signing up for a retailer’s credit card. The immediate discount gives customers an incentive to apply. The retailer, meanwhile, gains an opportunity to earn money through its credit card partnership.

A December 2024 report from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau examined the economics of retail credit cards and their importance to major merchants. The CFPB found that credit card income represented an average of approximately 8% of gross profits among a sample of major retailers that regularly disclosed the information between 2018 and 2023.

For selected retailers, credit card income represented as much as 14.8% of gross profit. The report also explained that retailers commonly receive a share of earnings from store credit cards issued in partnership with financial institutions.

Interest charges and late fees can generate revenue for card issuers, while retailers can benefit from their revenue-sharing arrangements. The strategy also encourages repeat purchases. Customers who have a store credit card may be more likely to return to that retailer for future shopping trips.

However, consumers should pay attention to annual percentage rates, promotional financing expiration dates, deferred interest provisions and late-payment penalties. An immediate checkout discount can become considerably more expensive if a balance is not managed properly.

Why Some Black Friday TVs Are Difficult to Compare

Televisions are among the most recognizable Black Friday doorbusters. Retailers regularly advertise major discounts on large-screen televisions, sometimes promoting savings of hundreds of dollars.

However, not every television advertised during Black Friday is necessarily identical to the model sold throughout the rest of the year. Some manufacturers produce retailer-exclusive models or slightly different configurations for specific sales channels.

Differences can include model numbers, specifications, included accessories and product configurations. This makes direct price comparisons more difficult. A shopper might see two televisions advertised at similar screen sizes and resolutions but discover that they have different model numbers or technical specifications.

Retailers also establish their own price-matching policies, which can include exclusions for limited-quantity doorbusters, special promotional products and marketplace sellers. Best Buy’s published promotional terms, for example, identify limited quantities, no rainchecks and offers subject to change as conditions attached to certain promotions.

The important distinction is that a television advertised at 70% off is not automatically comparable to another television with a similar advertised discount. The model number and actual specifications matter.

The Six-Per-Store Doorbuster Strategy

Limited-quantity promotions are another way retailers generate excitement without discounting their entire inventory. A store might advertise an extremely inexpensive television, gaming system or appliance while making only a small number available at that price.

Customers arrive early, sometimes waiting in line for hours, because they believe they have an opportunity to secure a major bargain. Once the limited inventory sells out, shoppers are already inside the store or browsing the retailer’s website.

They may purchase another television, a different appliance or something entirely unrelated. The original promotion has accomplished its purpose by attracting customers.

This is particularly effective when shoppers have already invested time traveling to a store or waiting in line. However, limited-quantity promotions do not guarantee that customers will make additional purchases. The strategy is designed to increase the opportunity for additional sales, not ensure them.

Why Black Friday Sales Start Weeks Before Thanksgiving

Black Friday is no longer a single shopping day. Retailers have increasingly extended promotional periods into October and early November, creating weeks of holiday sales events. This approach allows companies to spread customer demand across a longer period rather than relying exclusively on one Friday. It also creates additional opportunities to advertise products, collect customer information, encourage repeat visits and compete with other retailers.

Cyber Monday extends the promotional cycle even further, particularly for online shopping. According to Adobe Analytics, American consumers spent a record $11.8 billion online on Black Friday 2025, representing a 9.1% increase compared with the previous year.

Cyber Monday generated an even larger $14.25 billion in online spending, up 7.1% year over year. Together, Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday generated $44.2 billion in online spending during the 2025 Cyber Week period.

These numbers demonstrate why retailers have little incentive to limit their promotional activity to a single day. The longer shopping season creates more opportunities to generate sales.

The Real Difference Between Advertised Discounts and Online Prices

The difference between advertised discounts and actual online pricing becomes particularly interesting when examining Adobe’s holiday shopping data. Adobe tracks online prices across product categories, providing a different perspective from studies that examine advertised retail promotions.

During the 2025 holiday season, Adobe reported peak online discounts of approximately:

Product category Peak discount
Electronics 31%
Toys 28%
Apparel 25%
Computers 23%
Televisions 22%
Furniture 19%
Appliances 19%
Sporting goods 17%

These figures represent peak discounts from listed prices, not the average savings on every product throughout the season. The distinction is important. WalletHub’s 74.08% JCPenney figure represents the average advertised discount in its sample of deals. Adobe’s figures measure online discount levels across product categories using its own methodology.

They are not directly comparable measurements. Nevertheless, the difference helps explain why an advertisement promising 70% off can look considerably more generous than the actual price reductions commonly observed across online retail categories.

Free Gift Cards Encourage Customers to Return

Another familiar Black Friday promotion involves bonus gift cards. A retailer might advertise a $200 purchase that comes with a $25 promotional gift card. The customer receives an additional incentive to shop, but the retailer also creates a reason for that customer to return.

Promotional gift cards frequently come with redemption conditions, including minimum purchase requirements, limited redemption windows or restrictions on eligible merchandise. A shopper returning to spend the $25 might purchase $60 worth of merchandise.

The retailer has generated another transaction and potentially increased the customer’s overall spending. Gift cards also have an accounting concept known as breakage.

Breakage refers to the portion of gift card balances that companies reasonably expect customers will never redeem. Under applicable accounting rules, retailers can recognize certain expected unredeemed balances as revenue when the relevant requirements are met. State laws can also affect whether unused balances must be transferred to the government.

However, companies cannot simply treat every newly issued gift card as immediate profit. The original sale generally creates an obligation to provide merchandise or services when the card is redeemed.

Buy Now, Pay Later Makes Expensive Purchases Easier

Black Friday promotions increasingly include buy now, pay later financing. These services allow customers to divide purchases into multiple payments, sometimes without interest when payments are made according to the agreement. For retailers, installment payments can reduce the immediate financial barrier associated with expensive merchandise.

A customer who might hesitate to spend $800 upfront could be more willing to complete the purchase when offered smaller scheduled payments. Adobe reported that buy now, pay later purchases generated more than $1 billion in online spending on Cyber Monday 2025.

The financing industry also generates revenue through merchant fees and, depending on the provider and product, consumer interest or fees. For retailers, the attraction is straightforward: making purchases easier to finance can help convert shoppers who might otherwise abandon their shopping carts. However, multiple installment purchases can accumulate quickly, particularly during the holiday season.

Why Retailers Make Money on Clothing, Toys and Beauty Products

Black Friday is not just about televisions and electronics. Clothing, toys, beauty products, cosmetics and personal care merchandise also play an important role in holiday shopping. These categories provide retailers with opportunities to sell multiple products in one transaction.

A customer purchasing discounted clothing might also buy shoes, accessories and additional items for gifts. Beauty retailers can encourage customers to purchase gift sets, skincare collections, fragrances and makeup bundles.

Toy retailers benefit from customers purchasing several gifts at once, particularly when parents are shopping for multiple children. Bundled products are another important strategy.

Instead of purchasing individual items separately, customers may be offered a collection of products at a combined promotional price. Retailers can use these bundles to move merchandise, increase average transaction values and introduce shoppers to additional brands.

The actual profitability depends on the cost of merchandise, supplier agreements, promotional expenses and other operating costs. A 50% discount does not automatically mean a retailer is losing money.

Black Friday Deals Extend Beyond Traditional Retail

The Black Friday business model has expanded well beyond department stores and electronics retailers. Automotive companies, airlines, hotels, streaming platforms and subscription services also use seasonal promotions to attract customers.

Car dealerships may advertise special financing or promotional lease offers. Airlines and travel companies use limited-time promotions to encourage customers to book flights and vacations. Streaming platforms and digital subscription businesses can offer introductory pricing to attract new subscribers.

These businesses operate differently from traditional retail stores, but the underlying strategy is similar. An introductory promotion can help acquire a customer who may continue paying for a service after the discount expires. For subscription businesses, the long-term value of a customer can be considerably more important than the initial promotional payment.

January Returns Create Another Challenge for Retailers

Black Friday purchases do not always become permanent sales. Some holiday merchandise is returned after Christmas, creating additional expenses for retailers. Returned products require processing, inspection, transportation and, in some cases, repackaging or resale at a reduced price.

According to the National Retail Federation’s 2025 Retail Returns Landscape report, retailers expected approximately $849.9 billion in merchandise returns across the retail industry during 2025. That represented an estimated 15.8% of annual retail sales.

The NRF and Happy Returns also estimated that approximately 17% of holiday sales would be returned. January is particularly important because many consumers wait until after the holidays to return unwanted gifts, duplicate purchases and merchandise that does not fit.

Returns can reduce the profitability of holiday promotions, although retailers also view convenient return policies as a way to maintain customer loyalty. Some customers who return merchandise make another purchase during the same visit.

Others use their store credit to shop post-holiday clearance events. For retailers, returns are therefore both an operational expense and an opportunity to encourage another transaction.

Why Some Stores Choose Not to Participate in Black Friday

Not every retailer believes opening its doors for Black Friday is worth the expense. REI has become one of the most recognizable examples of a company choosing a different approach. The outdoor retailer has repeatedly closed its stores on Thanksgiving and Black Friday through its Opt Outside initiative.

The company pays employees while encouraging customers to spend time outdoors rather than shopping. This approach demonstrates that retailers do not necessarily need to participate in every major promotional event to maintain their brand identity.

Other major retailers have also chosen to close on Thanksgiving, including Walmart, Target, Macy’s and JCPenney in 2025, while reopening for Black Friday. For these companies, the decision to close on Thanksgiving does not mean abandoning Black Friday promotions. Instead, it reflects a different approach to scheduling employees and operating during the holiday shopping period.

How Much Money Is at Stake in the 2026 Holiday Shopping Season?

The financial stakes surrounding Black Friday continue to grow. The National Retail Federation forecast in October 2026 that U.S. retail sales during November and December would increase 4.2% compared with 2025, reaching approximately $1.013 trillion.

For comparison, the NRF reported that 2025 holiday sales reached $972 billion, an increase of 3.1% over 2024. The 2026 forecast marks a major milestone because it projects holiday spending above $1 trillion.

Retailers are competing for a share of that spending through earlier promotions, online advertising, loyalty programs, financing options and aggressive discounting. The competition is particularly important as consumers continue looking for ways to stretch their budgets.

For retailers, the challenge is balancing attractive promotions with the need to protect profit margins. A company that discounts too aggressively risks sacrificing profitability. A company that offers weak promotions risks losing customers to competitors.

The most successful promotional strategies are designed to accomplish both objectives: attract shoppers with competitive prices while generating additional revenue through the rest of the shopping experience.

The Bottom Line: Black Friday Is About More Than Discounted Merchandise

A television advertised at 70% off might look like an extraordinary bargain, but that single price tag does not explain how the retailer makes money. The business model involves multiple revenue opportunities, including additional merchandise, accessories, warranties, store credit cards, gift cards, financing arrangements and repeat purchases.

Some products are discounted aggressively because retailers want to attract customers. Other promotions help move inventory that companies need to sell before the end of the year. Meanwhile, limited-quantity doorbusters and promotional advertising create urgency that encourages shoppers to make purchases.

The biggest takeaway is that retailers are not necessarily trying to make substantial money on every individual product. They are trying to make the entire shopping experience profitable. And that is how a store can advertise merchandise at 70% off while still operating a business designed to generate revenue.

For consumers, the lesson is simple: The percentage displayed on a Black Friday advertisement is not the same thing as the amount of money actually saved. Comparing recent prices, checking product model numbers and understanding financing terms can reveal considerably more about a deal than the promotional sign ever will.