Reclaiming Patriotism: Why Democrats Must Not Let Republicans Co-Opt the American Flag
In the evolving landscape of American politics, the concept of patriotism has increasingly been co-opted by the Republican Party, framing it as an exclusive component of their identity. Democrats cannot afford to let this continue. If Democrats allow Republicans to monopolize the idea of patriotism, they risk losing ground on one of the most powerful emotional and political forces in American life: the love of country. It’s essential for Democrats to assert their own brand of patriotism — one rooted in inclusion, progress, and the core values that the nation was founded on.
The GOP’s Claim to Patriotism
The Republican Party has long tied its political messaging to symbols of traditional patriotism, such as the American flag, military strength, and conservative values tied to national pride. This trend accelerated during the Trump era, where “America First” became the rallying cry, and those who disagreed with certain policies were often portrayed as un-American.
Trump’s rallies became a showcase of hyper-patriotic displays, where American flags, red “Make America Great Again” hats, and chants of “USA!” were woven into the very fabric of the event. The Republican narrative leaned into a brand of patriotism that equated loyalty to the nation with loyalty to conservative ideals. Criticism of policies like the Muslim ban, anti-immigration rhetoric, or environmental deregulation were painted as unpatriotic, anti-American actions by the opposing party.
This branding not only secured Republican loyalty but created an unfortunate binary perception: to be patriotic was to be Republican; to be a Democrat was, at best, to love the idea of America less. This narrative is dangerous because it oversimplifies the notion of patriotism and alienates millions of Americans who love their country just as deeply but envision its greatness in different terms.
The Democratic Vision of Patriotism
Patriotism, in its true sense, is not exclusive to any political party. Democrats must reclaim patriotism by presenting a vision of America that emphasizes the nation’s founding ideals of equality, liberty, and justice for all. It’s critical to assert that loving one’s country means seeking to improve it — not through empty slogans but through tangible actions that create a better future for everyone, regardless of race, religion, gender, or background.
For Democrats, patriotism should be about progress. The party has long been the champion of civil rights, expanding healthcare, environmental protection, and supporting workers’ rights — all of which are quintessentially American goals. Democrats should tie these causes directly to patriotism, illustrating that advocating for progress is inherently a patriotic act. Protecting voting rights, addressing climate change, ensuring racial justice, and expanding economic opportunities for all Americans are deeply aligned with American values.
Democrats should also redefine national pride in terms of civic engagement and community service. From teachers and nurses to soldiers and civil rights activists, the backbone of America is built on the efforts of those who serve their communities. This broader understanding of service should be a cornerstone of the Democratic vision of patriotism, one that celebrates the contributions of everyday citizens in maintaining the health and progress of the nation.
Patriotism Through Diversity and Inclusion
At the heart of the Democratic vision is the belief that America’s greatest strength lies in its diversity. While Republicans often tout a more rigid version of patriotism tied to traditional symbols, Democrats can embrace a vision of national pride that celebrates the evolving, multifaceted identity of the country.
The American experiment has always been about expanding the definition of who belongs in the idea of “We the People.” From the abolition of slavery to the women’s suffrage movement, from the Civil Rights Movement to the fight for LGBTQ+ rights, America has always progressed toward a more inclusive society. This is the patriotic vision that Democrats must champion: one that acknowledges the greatness of America while recognizing that the country’s strength comes from its constant push to live up to its founding ideals.
America’s diversity is not a liability, as some far-right nationalists claim, but rather a foundational asset. The immigrant story is a fundamentally American one. Many Democratic leaders, including former Presidents Barack Obama and Joe Biden, have framed this narrative as part of the American dream — a dream where anyone, regardless of where they come from, can succeed in America. This is patriotism in its purest form: belief in the promise of America and a dedication to making that promise available to all.
Strengthening Civic Institutions
Another area where Democrats can reclaim patriotism is through a renewed commitment to civic institutions. The Democratic Party has often been at the forefront of defending democratic norms — fighting voter suppression, advocating for campaign finance reform, and standing up for an independent judiciary. These are not just procedural battles; they are fights for the heart of American democracy. They are inherently patriotic struggles, focused on preserving the framework of self-governance that makes America unique.
By emphasizing the protection of democratic institutions, Democrats can offer a vision of patriotism that goes beyond symbolic displays. True patriotism isn’t just about waving the flag; it’s about ensuring that every citizen’s vote counts and that the rule of law is upheld.
Countering the “Anti-American” Narrative
Democrats need to counter the dangerous idea that criticism of the country is synonymous with hating it. Republicans often paint movements like Black Lives Matter or environmental activism as “anti-American” because they challenge the status quo. However, the opposite is true: to engage in activism for justice and equality is to deeply believe in the American promise. The Constitution itself was designed to allow for change and improvement. Democrats should remind voters that striving for a more perfect union is not just patriotic but part of the American tradition.
Martin Luther King Jr.’s famous line, “America, be true to what you said on paper,” is a perfect encapsulation of this form of patriotism. King’s critique of racial injustice was not rooted in disdain for America but in his love for its ideals. Democrats must continually assert that fighting for social justice, equality, and fairness is not only patriotic but an essential part of keeping the American dream alive.
Reclaiming the Flag
Democrats cannot afford to cede the powerful, emotional narrative of patriotism to the Republican Party. The flag, the anthem, the symbols of America belong to all Americans, not just one political faction. Democrats must present their version of patriotism — one that is forward-looking, inclusive, and rooted in the true meaning of democracy. To be patriotic is to believe in the potential of this country, to fight for its people, and to strive for a better, more just future for all. The Democratic vision of patriotism must be one where progress, diversity, and the pursuit of equality are as American as the flag itself.
South Florida Media Comments