How Much Profit Does an NYC Restaurant Make on a $16 Chicken Sandwich?

A $16 fried chicken sandwich might sound like a profitable menu item, but the reality of running a restaurant in New York City tells a very different story. Chef Eric Huang, founder of Chinatown restaurant Pecking House, is revealing just how little money his business keeps from each sandwich after accounting for food, employee wages, rent and operating expenses.

According to Huang, the restaurant makes approximately $2.30 to $2.40 in profit on a $16 fried chicken sandwich. That represents roughly 15% of the selling price, illustrating the financial pressures facing independent restaurants even when their food attracts customers and generates attention on social media.

Huang recently offered an inside look at the restaurant’s finances, explaining why rising ingredient costs, expensive labor and New York City’s operating expenses make it increasingly difficult for small restaurant owners to stay profitable.

Breaking Down the $16 Chicken Sandwich

Huang explained that Pecking House aims to keep food costs between 25% and 30% of the sandwich’s selling price. Labor accounts for another 28% to 35%, depending on the month, while rent, occupancy expenses and other overhead consume approximately 20%.

After those expenses, the restaurant is left with an estimated profit margin of around 15%. That means a sandwich selling for $16 generates approximately $4 in food costs, between $4.48 and $5.60 in labor expenses, and roughly $3.20 in rent and other overhead. The remaining amount is approximately $2.40, although actual profitability can fluctuate depending on operating costs and business conditions. Huang emphasized that the numbers reflect how quickly expenses can eat into what customers see as a relatively expensive menu item.

Rising Food Costs Are Cutting Into Restaurant Profits

One of Huang’s biggest concerns is the rising cost of ingredients, particularly cooking oil and bread. Pecking House uses Japanese milk bread for its chicken sandwiches, sourced from Parisian Bakery in New Jersey. Huang said the cost of bread has increased by approximately 30 to 40 cents per loaf, while delivery companies have also introduced fuel surcharges.

As a result, the bread cost per sandwich has increased from approximately $1 to between $1.25 and $1.30. Cooking oil has become another significant expense. Huang said he previously paid $29.99 for a 35-pound container of canola oil. That price has climbed above $40.

His restaurant goes through approximately 15 to 20 containers every week. The increase translates into an additional $200 in weekly expenses, or approximately $800 to $900 per month. For an independent restaurant operating on relatively small profit margins, those increases can make a substantial difference.

Rent and Employee Wages Add More Financial Pressure

Operating a restaurant in New York City comes with substantial real estate and labor expenses. Huang said Pecking House pays approximately $4,900 per month for its Chinatown location. The relatively modest rent comes with a trade-off: The restaurant is situated beneath the Manhattan Bridge in an area with limited pedestrian traffic.

The business originally anticipated relying heavily on takeout and delivery orders. However, Huang said walk-in customers now account for approximately 60% to 70% of its business.

Staffing has also changed significantly since the restaurant’s earlier days in Brooklyn. Huang previously employed approximately 30 people at the Brooklyn location. His current Chinatown operation has six employees, making the smaller business easier to manage. He explained that reducing the restaurant’s footprint and staffing requirements has helped create a more sustainable operating model.

A Viral Restaurant With an Unpredictable Business Model

Pecking House’s popularity can be traced back to its beginnings during the COVID-19 pandemic. Huang previously worked in fine dining, including as a sous chef at Eleven Madison Park. In 2020, he began experimenting with fried chicken through his family’s Queens restaurant, eventually launching Pecking House as a delivery-focused pop-up.

The concept attracted significant attention, at one point generating a waitlist of approximately 10,000 customers. In 2022, Huang opened a permanent restaurant in Brooklyn before expanding into Manhattan’s Chinatown in 2024.

Social media has continued to bring attention to the business, particularly videos featuring its signature Sichuan chili fried chicken. However, viral attention does not necessarily translate into consistent revenue. Huang said the restaurant can experience extremely busy periods when videos gain traction online, followed by slower weeks when social media attention fades.

He estimated that Pecking House had already sold nearly 10,000 chicken sandwiches during 2026, almost twice the number sold during the previous year. Despite the demand, maintaining consistent daily sales remains challenging.

How Much Money Does Pecking House Need to Make Each Day?

Huang said his ideal goal would be generating between $2,000 and $2,500 in daily sales. However, business fluctuates throughout the week, with Saturdays typically bringing the largest crowds.

The restaurant’s record daily sales reached approximately $6,000, although Huang described that level of activity as difficult to manage rather than an ideal everyday situation. His experience highlights a broader challenge for independent restaurant owners: High sales do not automatically translate into substantial profits. Food expenses, employee compensation, rent, insurance, utilities and other operating costs must all be covered before a restaurant can determine what it actually earns.

The Reality Behind Restaurant Menu Prices

Huang’s financial breakdown offers a closer look at why independent restaurants often charge more than customers might expect. In a September 2025 breakdown published by Huang himself, he calculated that the ingredients and packaging for Pecking House’s chili chicken sandwich cost approximately $5.06.

That calculation included the chicken thigh, Japanese milk bread, pickles, mayonnaise, butter, flour, chili oil, buttermilk marinade and packaging. He also explained that delivery platforms introduce additional expenses that can make online orders less profitable than in-store purchases.

The numbers demonstrate why a $16 sandwich cannot be evaluated simply by subtracting the cost of its main ingredients from its menu price. For independent restaurant owners, the challenge is balancing affordability for customers with the financial realities of keeping a business operational. Huang’s experience at Pecking House illustrates how even a popular, social media-famous restaurant can operate on relatively narrow margins.

Ultimately, a $16 fried chicken sandwich generates approximately $2.30 to $2.40 in estimated profit for Pecking House, according to Huang. The remaining money goes toward the expenses required to keep the restaurant running.