The Root Beer Wars: A&W vs. Barq’s vs. Mug vs. Hires
For generations, root beer has been one of America’s most recognizable soft drinks. From frosty mugs at roadside diners to bottles lining grocery store shelves, the sweet, bubbly beverage has built a loyal following across the country.
But behind the familiar labels is a competitive history involving some of the biggest beverage companies in the world. A&W, Barq’s, Mug and Hires each helped shape the American root beer market. Their stories involve century-old recipes, aggressive advertising, corporate acquisitions and competition for space in an increasingly crowded soda industry.
Known as the Root Beer Wars, the competition intensified as major beverage corporations acquired established brands and fought for a larger share of the market.
How Root Beer Became an American Favorite
Root beer has roots stretching back centuries, originating from traditional beverages made with roots, herbs, bark and berries. Early versions were prepared at home by combining ingredients, brewing them and adding sweeteners.
The commercial root beer industry gained national attention in 1876 when Philadelphia pharmacist Charles Elmer Hires introduced his version of the beverage at the Centennial Exhibition in Philadelphia.
Hires marketed the drink as a convenient alternative to traditional homemade preparations. His product helped establish root beer as a recognizable commercial beverage and encouraged other entrepreneurs to enter the growing market. By the early 20th century, several competing brands had emerged, setting the stage for decades of competition.
The Four Brands Behind the Root Beer Wars
A&W: The Roadside Stand That Became a National Brand
A&W traces its history to June 20, 1919, when Roy W. Allen opened a root beer stand in Lodi, California. Allen initially sold root beer for five cents a mug during a celebration welcoming home World War I veterans. The business became successful, and Allen eventually partnered with Frank Wright.
The partners established the A&W name using their last initials and expanded the operation through additional stands and franchising. By 1925, A&W was selling franchises, helping establish what became one of America’s earliest restaurant franchise chains.
The brand eventually became closely associated with frosty glass mugs, root beer floats and roadside dining. A&W Root Beer entered grocery stores in bottles and cans in 1971, expanding its reach beyond its restaurants. Today, A&W Root Beer is part of the Keurig Dr Pepper beverage portfolio, while A&W Restaurants operates separately.
Barq’s: The Root Beer With a Different Taste
Barq’s entered the market in 1898, when Edward Barq began producing root beer in Biloxi, Mississippi. Unlike some competitors, Barq’s developed a reputation for a sharper flavor profile. Its traditional formula also distinguished itself through caffeine, setting it apart from many other root beer brands.
The company expanded beyond its original regional market as demand grew. One of the most important moments in Barq’s history came in 1995, when The Coca-Cola Company acquired the brand.
The acquisition brought Barq’s into the portfolio of one of the world’s largest beverage corporations and intensified competition among major soda manufacturers. Barq’s remains a recognizable name in the American root beer market and is owned by Coca-Cola.
Mug: Pepsi’s Entry Into the Root Beer Competition
Mug Root Beer developed from a San Francisco beverage business that originally marketed its product as Belfast Root Beer. The brand eventually became known as Mug Old Fashioned Root Beer and expanded beyond its original regional market.
During the 1980s, PepsiCo acquired Mug, giving the company an established product in the root beer category. Mug became one of the major competitors in a market increasingly dominated by large beverage manufacturers.
Its recognizable bulldog mascot and distinctive packaging helped establish its identity among consumers. Today, Mug is associated with PepsiCo and remains one of the best-known root beer brands in the United States.
Hires: The Brand That Helped Start It All
Hires has one of the longest histories of the four brands. Charles Elmer Hires introduced his commercial root beer at Philadelphia’s 1876 Centennial Exhibition, helping bring the beverage into mainstream American commerce.
His original product was marketed as a mixture of roots, herbs and berries. Consumers could purchase preparations to make root beer at home, helping the brand establish an early national presence.
For decades, Hires was among the most recognizable names in the category. However, the company eventually faced growing competition from newer brands, changing consumer preferences and increasing pressure from larger beverage manufacturers.
The Hires family sold its majority interest in the business in 1960. The brand subsequently passed through several corporate owners before becoming part of the Dr Pepper Snapple Group, which later became Keurig Dr Pepper. Hires is now primarily a legacy name in the American root beer story and is no longer prominently featured in Keurig Dr Pepper’s current beverage portfolio.
When the Root Beer Wars Became a Corporate Battle
The competition became particularly interesting during the 1990s, when major beverage companies began consolidating some of the industry’s best-known root beer brands.
The 1995 acquisition of Barq’s by Coca-Cola intensified competition among the industry’s major players.
The competitive landscape included three major corporate groups:
-
Coca-Cola: Barq’s Root Beer.
-
PepsiCo: Mug Root Beer.
-
Cadbury Schweppes: A&W and Hires Root Beer.
These acquisitions gave major beverage manufacturers established brands with existing customers, recognizable packaging and decades of consumer loyalty. The competition was not limited to taste. Distribution networks, grocery store shelf space, advertising budgets and brand recognition all played important roles.
Smaller regional root beer producers also competed for customers by emphasizing traditional brewing methods, distinctive ingredients and locally developed recipes.
Who Owns the Major Root Beer Brands Today?
The corporate landscape has changed since the original competition intensified.
| Brand | Corporate connection |
|---|---|
| A&W | Keurig Dr Pepper |
| Barq’s | The Coca-Cola Company |
| Mug | PepsiCo |
| Hires | Historical brand associated with Keurig Dr Pepper |
One important distinction is that A&W Restaurants and A&W Root Beer are not the same business operation. The restaurant chain operates separately from the packaged beverage business.
Hires also has a different place in today’s market. Although it remains an important part of root beer history, it is no longer prominently featured among Keurig Dr Pepper’s current ready-to-drink brands.
Why Root Beer Still Has a Loyal Following
Despite competition from cola, lemon-lime sodas, energy drinks and newer beverage categories, root beer continues to occupy a recognizable place in American food culture.
Part of its appeal comes from its distinctive flavor. Unlike traditional cola, root beer typically uses a combination of botanical-inspired flavors, including vanilla, wintergreen, licorice and other herbs and spices. The beverage is also closely associated with American diners, drive-in restaurants, ice cream parlors and the classic root beer float.
Different brands have developed their own identities. Some consumers prefer the traditional sweetness associated with A&W, while others gravitate toward Barq’s sharper flavor or Mug’s familiar taste. Regional craft producers have also helped maintain interest in the category by offering alternative recipes and ingredients.
The Root Beer Wars Are Far From a Simple Taste Test
The competition between A&W, Barq’s, Mug and Hires represents more than a disagreement over which soda tastes best. It reflects how American beverage companies built powerful portfolios by acquiring established brands, expanding distribution and competing for consumer loyalty.
Hires helped introduce commercial root beer to a national audience in the 19th century. A&W transformed the beverage into a roadside restaurant staple. Barq’s developed a distinctive identity, while Mug became an important part of PepsiCo’s beverage lineup.
Today, the brands have very different positions in the marketplace, but their histories remain connected through one of America’s most recognizable soft drink categories. And while consumers may never agree on which root beer deserves the top spot, the competition helped turn a traditional herbal beverage into a lasting American favorite.
















Loading comments…